(Originally published April 11, 2021)
The year is 1945. World War II is finally over, the Allies have defeated the Axis, and only the United States out of all the major combatants retains its pre-war economic health. Acting in both humanitarian and self-interest, the United States establishes the Marshall Plan to rebuild much of western Europe, including Germany and Italy, and engages in the rebuilding of Japan, Taiwan, and South Korea as well.
Over the next 75 years, the United States will have provided economic assistance to Vietnam, China, and Mexico, as well as opening its markets to goods and services from the EU countries, Canada, Australia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Chile, and Argentina, essentially serving as the world’s economic engine for the second half of the 20th century.
The United States helped establish the United Nations, NATO, fought wars in Korea, Vietnam, Afghanistan, and Iraq to prevent the uncontrolled spread of totalitarianism and terrorism, essentially serving as the world’s peacekeeper.
Following the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, the United States was left as the world’s only superpower, and the U.S. continued its dual role as the world’s economic engine and the world’s peacekeeper. The sense of superiority and manifest destiny that the U.S. developed during this time led to widespread resentment in many regions of the world. By and large, the U.S. chose to ignore this resentment and assumed that its dominance would last forever.
The U.S. is stuck in a restless, feverish dream, part Alice in Wonderland and part Rip Van Winkle, rabbit holes and magic potions, rulers with huge egos and cackling laughs, twenty years lost and more. We need to wake up to reality. The era of unopposed U.S. dominance is over. How we respond now will determine to what extent the U.S. remains relevant moving forward.
The emergence of China as a world superpower is a fact. Its one-party totalitarian government has single-mindedly transformed a relatively backwards nation into a modern country. The fact that China was brought into the world of nations by the initiative of the United States means nothing to the Chinese. As one who has watched too many late-night Hong Kong Kung-Fu movies over the years, it comes as no surprise that Chinese leaders have taken full advantage of our openness and inattentiveness. Where we see betrayal, the Chinese see strategy. The Chinese have identified the weaknesses of western democracies and have exploited them to the greatest extent possible.
China has stolen intellectual property and cutting-edge technologies, including military technology, from the United States and the European Union. It has flooded our markets with cheap, substandard goods while keeping its own markets closed. It has committed willful negligence in allowing the Covid-19 virus to kill millions of non-Chinese and wreak havoc on the rest of the world’s economy. It has committed genocide on its own people, taken over Hong Kong in violation of its treaty agreement, expanded far into the South China Sea in violation of the United Nations Maritime agreement, and gives every indication that it is preparing to invade Taiwan.
This is not a country that appears to have any interest in joining the world of nations as an equal partner. This is a country whose intention appears to be to replace the U.S. as the dominant world power and to exert its influence globally to further its own self-interests. China has taken many actions to weaken the U.S. to achieve its goal and will continue to do so as long as the U.S. refuses to act.
While the U.S. has no manifest right to begrudge China’s success, the U.S. and the rest of the world of nations have every right to insist that China acknowledge the rights and sovereignty of other countries, to act in accordance with international laws, and to conduct its affairs without threats or intimidation.
It should be expected, however, that China will continue to act in an extremely disruptive and assertive manner, justifying its actions as those of an ancient empire re-establishing its historical imperial domination. President Chi is simply a modern-day Chinese emperor who revels in his power and intends to extend China’s dominion to reach every corner of the world. Chairman Mao’s teachings are destined to become a footnote in Chinese history.
Of course, Chinese dominion cannot be allowed to happen. China’s ambitions must be resisted until President Chi is dead in 20 years, or until the people of China recognize the hypocrisy of its corrupt government and rebel against its oppression and subjugation.
The recent Alaskan summit between the U.S. and China has clearly established that China has more contempt than it has respect for the U.S. and believes that the U.S. is in decline and lacks the will to assert itself. So be it. The U.S. has been challenged and must respond with a resoluteness and resolve that it has not shown in decades.
Given the degree of senseless partisanship, economic greed, and pointless division that currently exists within the U.S., this is going to be a problem.
Whatever the point of the summit was from the perspective of the U.S., the summit was clearly a diplomatic failure. There can and will be no constructive relationship between the U.S. and China that would see China adding to the established world order, enriching the world with its culture and technology, and contributing to the global effort to address issues that affect all nations.
However, the summit was a profound success in one regard. China seized this opportunity to express its rejection of the established world order that is based upon the concepts of peace and prosperity for all nations and all peoples, as well as its rejection of international agreements that are intended to advance and protect these concepts, and China confirmed its intention to pursue its own self-interests in an extremely aggressive and arrogant manner without regard to the interests of the rest of the world.
The U.S. may have been accused of imperialism in the past, but the world is about to experience true imperialism in the form of an ascendant China. The rest of the world has been given fair warning.
The U.S. needs to stop acting like China is its problem to solve. China is going to do what China is going to do. To what extent their actions end up destabilizing the world remains to be seen. The U.S. will be much better off focusing its efforts and energies towards strengthening its relationships with its existing allies, and in developing new political, economic and cultural relationships with as many other countries as possible.
The United Nations, for all its faults, is an important forum through which the U.S. is able to offer its leadership, resources, and world vision. The United Nations provides a forum to address Chinese aggression, to advocate for reform of the World Health Organization, to support the judicious use of the United Nations Security Forces, to coordinate various humanitarian initiatives, and to address the world of nations in a strategic manner that fosters goodwill and begins to erase decades of resentment and suspicion that many countries have towards the U.S.
Defensive alliances such as NATO and the agreements the U.S. has with Israel, Saudi Arabia, Japan, South Korea, Australia, and Taiwan form the basis for collective security against aggression by China, Russia, and Iran. Ensuring strong relationships with our most important allies is crucial to ensuring that our collective future will be peaceful and prosperous.
Improving relationships with India and Brazil is vital as well. These are large countries in both size and population, and we must ensure that they view the U.S. as an economic and cultural ally as well as a reliable and non-judgmental partner.
It is also important that the U.S. address our extremely negative and counterproductive relationships with Cuba, North Korea, and Venezuela. The U.S. must acknowledge its complicity in creating these relationships, whether due to an outcome of war, political manipulation, or economic coercion. The U.S. must begin to repair these relationships and reduce the level of animosity. The goal should be to have these countries become economic and cultural allies as well.
The sins that the United States has committed during the past 75 years are trivial when compared to the actions that China has and is taking. China has made it clear that their intention is to aggressively dominate the world militarily, economically, politically, and financially. This world domination was never the intent of the United States.
In hindsight, the interference by the U.S. in the affairs of other countries to protect corporate interests and to install democratic governments in countries where it had never existed before has generally been unsuccessful and detrimental to its national interests. This has ultimately made some countries very suspicious of the U.S. and more inclined to view the U.S. in a negative light instead of as a potential partner.
However, during this time the United States has never made any efforts to expand its territory, and in the cases of Panama and the Philippines, agreed to leave the country when asked to do so even though it was not in its national interest to do so. This willingness to be respectful of the sovereignty of other countries is the direct opposite of imperialism.
To expand upon the principle of reaching out to other countries and other peoples, let the U.S. truly be the country that welcomes all faiths. Religious faith forms the basis for living for many Americans, and faith plays an even more important role in other countries. One of the founding principles of the U.S. is to welcome all faiths but to separate religion from governance, and the importance of this principle to welcome all faiths should not be underestimated.
The U.S. has long spoken of its founding as a Christian nation. The Jewish faith has long been accepted as well, as shown by the concept of Judeo-Christian values. It is important to understand that there are religious teachings that transcend the boundaries of all faiths, universal teachings that allow all peoples to coexist. The inclusion of Islam, Hinduism, and Buddhism into the mainstream of religious thought is critical for the long-term security of the U.S.
The Islamic faith is the third Abrahamic religion along with Judaism and Christianity. The Islamic faith must be accepted as a legitimate and respected religious practice in the U.S. The U.S. must become known as a safe haven for Muslims as it has become for Jews. Islam is practiced by over a billion people. It is infinitely better to be a safe haven than to be the focus of Islamic terrorism.
Islam has not always been at odds with Christianity and Judaism. There is much to appreciate in the scientific contributions made by Islamic scholars, the preservation of Western thought during the Dark Ages, the construction of enumerable architectural marvels, and the artistic, literary, and cultural contributions made by the Arab peoples.
The Hindu faith is even older than Judaism and is practiced by over a billion people. Buddhism is an old faith as well, practiced by over half a billion people. There are Hindu and Buddhist temples throughout the U.S., a reflection of the changing U.S. immigration patterns over the past decades. Both religions bring their own profound histories and teachings and should be welcome additions to U.S. culture and its rich tapestry of faith.
After all, there are many names for God, and many paths to God, but there is only one God. One faith does not take away from another except in the minds of the ignorant and unenlightened. The sincere practice of any faith involves peace, humility, acceptance, and civility, with which this country could use more of.
So, given that China has clearly revealed its intention to challenge the U.S. in all matters, and weaken the U.S. in any way possible, what should the U.S. response be?
Acknowledge and accept the challenge, strategically and expeditiously address all known threats, and directly counter Chinese initiatives and propaganda whenever and wherever possible.
Here is a list of actions that the U.S. should be taking immediately:
- Address the illegal importation of fentanyl by completing the border wall at the U.S./Mexican border, expanding the inspection of goods being imported from China, and identifying alternatives to fentanyl demand.
- Accelerate security enhancements for all government, university, and corporate computer networks to prevent data theft and catastrophic system manipulation, and develop better methods of detecting and isolating electronic intrusion in real time.
- Prohibit the sale of advanced technologies by U.S. corporations to Chinese companies and third-party companies with Chinese ties, defining such sales as violations of national security and punishable by extremely large fines and extremely long prison sentences.
- Identify critical materials, products and equipment that can only be sourced from Chinese companies and accelerate the development of domestic and allied sources to address current Chinese supply chain vulnerabilities.
- Prohibit Chinese university students from having any involvement in technology-focused research projects at U.S. universities, prohibit partnerships between U.S. research institutions and their Chinese counterparts, and prohibit the issuance of any technology-focused work visas for any Chinese citizens.
- Prohibit the purchase of Chinese-sourced equipment for any critical infrastructure, national defense, and telecommunications applications.
- Develop a U.S. and allied version of the Chinese Belt and Bridges initiative to provide economic and infrastructure aide to South American, Central American, Southeast Asian, and African nations that is based upon grants and not loans.
- Retain the tariffs imposed on various Chinese goods and expand the scope of the tariffs as required to protect domestic manufacturers from unfair trading practices and to equalize the cost of goods.
The U.S. must establish limits to Chinese access – access to our politics, our corporations, our universities, and our economy. The U.S. cannot afford to ignore the extent to which China has exploited the openness of our society and taken full advantage of the greed and self-interest that has motivated so many of the decisions Americans in power have made over the years.
These decisions have made many Americans and corporations very wealthy. Many Americans and corporations continue to have a strong economic interest in preserving the current relationship with China, despite this clearly not being in the best interests of the U.S. There must be social, economic, and criminal penalties instituted to discourage such decision making.
The world is in a very unsettled place right now. The U.S. must find a way to stop the forces of division acting within itself and realize that the true danger to its way of life is not from other countries but from within.
China offers the world a future where great things can be achieved through collective effort, but at the loss of personal choice, personal expression, and personal belief. China crushes dissent, crushes religion, and crushes its people’s spirit in order to achieve obedience and conformity.
Countries where there is personal freedom tempered with a sense of social responsibility, a healthy democracy with a free press, and minimal governmental corruption are more prosperous, vibrant and creative than those countries that do not have these attributes.
At present, unfortunately, the U.S falls far short of this ideal. The U.S. has personal freedom without a sense of social responsibility, a dysfunctional democracy with a press focused on creating conflict and generating profits at the expense of truth and enlightenment, and a government corrupted by career politicians, lobbyists, and unlimited dark money spent on thought control.
Yet, despite all these issues, the promise of freedom and opportunity that the U.S. represents is why so many people try so hard to immigrate to the U.S. by any means possible. In contrast, why would anyone choose to immigrate to China? Does anyone ever immigrate to China, besides starving worm-infested soldiers from North Korea?
The U.S. must accept that China is a formidable adversary, with whom we will have economic and political conflict for the foreseeable future, i.e., decades. Diplomacy, treaties, and agreements will change nothing because China has repeatedly shown that they will honor nothing.
The U.S. must resolve to defend itself and its interests forcefully and assertively, year after year after year. It must strengthen its existing alliances and develop new alliances with all due haste, and it must learn to welcome other religions so that the U.S. becomes a safe haven for all faiths.
Beyond that, the U.S. and its allies must realize that the existing world order should not be seen as an order defined by Western culture and values, but instead as an order intended to achieve a peaceful and profitable coexistence, raise the standard of living of all the world’s people, and make sure that our planet remains habitable.
When looked at from this perspective, it would be infinitely better if China ended up being a vital contributor to the world order instead of acting as a threat to it. Ultimately, for all of our sakes – U.S. and China alike – this must be the outcome, and this must be the message that the U.S. brings to the world.